Contents
The make-or-buy decision for apps is this: do you have your own app developed, or do you use ready-made standard software or a SaaS product? The short answer: buy what is standard and build what sets you apart from the competition. The criteria, decision matrix and cost comparison in this article show how to judge your specific case.
What "make" and "buy" actually mean for apps
The line is more blurred than the terms suggest. In practice, there are four variants:
- Buy: you license a finished solution, often as a per-user subscription, and only adjust settings.
- Buy and configure: the standard software offers builders, form designers or low-code extensions to adapt workflows.
- Hybrid: standard software handles the core function (e.g. ERP, shop system, accounting) and a custom app provides the interface for your customers or employees on top of it.
- Make: fully custom development in which you control features, design, data and source code.
The hybrid variant in particular is often overlooked, yet it is the most economical solution in many mid-sized company projects.
The key decision criteria
1. Differentiation
Is the process the app supports a competitive advantage? A customer app that makes your particular service promise tangible justifies custom development more readily than a leave-management tool that works the same in every company.
2. Process fit
How far would you need to adapt your workflow to the standard software? Small adjustments can even be beneficial, because standard processes are proven. But if core steps can only be mapped with workarounds, you create permanent friction.
3. Integration
Does the solution need to exchange data with several existing systems? Standard software offers connectors for common systems, but perhaps not for your specific landscape.
4. Lifetime cost
Licence fees scale with the number of users; development costs are mostly one-off, plus maintenance. The calculation must therefore span several years.
5. Control and dependency
Who owns the data and features? What happens if the vendor raises prices, removes features or shuts down the service? With custom development and full source code rights, control stays with you.
6. Time to use
Standard software is often ready in days or weeks. Custom development takes from a few weeks to several months, depending on scope.
Decision matrix: make or buy at a glance
| Criterion | Points to buy | Points to make |
|---|---|---|
| Differentiation | Commodity process, the same everywhere | Core process, part of your competitive edge |
| Process fit | Standard workflow fits 80 % or more | Essential steps only possible with workarounds |
| Number of users | Few users, moderate licence fees | Many users or external customers, licence fees grow steeply |
| Integration | Ready-made connectors to your systems | Specific system landscape, custom interfaces required |
| Brand experience | Internal use, design secondary | Customer-facing, own branding and store presence matter |
| Time pressure | Solution needed immediately | A few weeks of lead time are possible |
| Data and compliance | Vendor demonstrably meets your requirements | Special requirements for data storage, hosting or auditability |
Weight the criteria for your situation and assess both options honestly. If most point clearly in one direction, the decision is usually obvious. If the picture is mixed, take a closer look at the hybrid variant.
Comparing costs over five years
A fair comparison looks at total cost over the planned period of use. For standard software, that includes licences, implementation, configuration, training and interface costs. For custom development, it includes development, hosting, maintenance and further development.
As guide values for custom development from our price range: a simple app EUR 5,000–15,000, a mid-complexity app with login, payments and API for iOS and Android EUR 15,000–50,000, complex platforms from EUR 50,000. Annual operating and maintenance costs come on top. Our article on total cost of ownership of an app over five years explains the full calculation.
A simple worked example for orientation: if a SaaS solution costs EUR 20 per user per month, that is EUR 24,000 per year for 100 users – EUR 120,000 over five years, excluding implementation. A mid-range custom app plus maintenance may well be cheaper in this scenario. With ten users, the numbers look completely different. Plug in your own figures.
When low-code or no-code is a middle path
Between buying and building sit low-code and no-code platforms. They suit internal forms, simple workflows and prototypes. Their limits show with complex logic, performance, app store presence and dependency on the platform. See no-code vs. low-code vs. custom development for a detailed comparison.
Reaching a make-or-buy decision in 5 steps
- Capture requirements: core process, user groups, interfaces, data protection needs, timeframe.
- Research the market: identify two or three suitable standard solutions and test them with real workflows, not just demos.
- Assess the gaps: which requirements does the standard solution not meet, and how critical are those gaps?
- Compare costs: a five-year view for buy, make and hybrid with realistic user numbers.
- Check the exit: how do you get your data back with each option if you want to switch later?
For the make option, we provide a fixed-price offer after a free analysis via our offer request – a solid basis for comparing options with real numbers. For how digitalisation projects in mid-sized companies are approached overall, see app development for SMEs.
Agentic coding workshop for your team? From €799 net – request a quote by e-mailConclusion
Make or buy is not a matter of principle but a trade-off for each use case. Standard software is right for standard processes with a manageable number of users. A custom app pays off when it supports a differentiating process, reaches many users or connects a specific system landscape. And often a combination of both is the best answer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a custom app always more expensive than standard software?
Not over its full lifetime. With many users or external customers, recurring licence fees can exceed the one-off development cost plus maintenance after a few years.
What is a hybrid solution in make or buy?
Standard software handles the core function, such as ERP or a shop system, and a custom app provides a tailored interface for customers or employees on top. This combines proven systems with your own user experience.
How do I avoid dependency on a software vendor?
Check data export options, contract terms and notice periods. With custom development, full source code rights and accounts in your name secure your independence.
How long does a make-or-buy analysis take?
For a clearly defined application, two to four weeks are often enough, including tests of standard solutions and a cost estimate for custom development.